But how much of that certainty was the result of the song played over the closing credits?
I'll get to that in a minute.
First, Toni Erdmann has been rolling around in my head for the last few weeks, even before other events conspired to make me question how the strength of my feelings about it was forged. And those thoughts are all around the movie's star, Sandra Huller.
Simply put, is there a more surefire bet for a movie's quality than the fact that Sandra Huller has chosen to appear in it?
Last weekend I went out to see Fatherland, the latest film from Polish director and black and white specialist Pawel Pawlikowski. I loved his 2013 film Ida, making it my #3 of the year of its international release in 2014, and was less enamored with his 2018 film Cold War. Because life is unfair, it's taken Pawlikwoski another eight years to make his next feature, even though each of the three I've mentioned is under 90 minutes in length. (That doesn't actually have anything to do with it, of course.) In fact, if not for Cold War's audacious 89-minute runtime, I could say that each was under 82 minutes, as both Ida and Fatherland clock in at exactly that length.
Alas, Fatherland is, for me, closer to Cold War than to Ida. Everyone says it's brilliant, and from a filmmaking standpoint, that's certainly true. But Pawlikowski's sparse approach left something to be desired for me on this one. Maybe I just needed the themes to be spelled out for me a bit more. I can be thick like that sometimes.
In any case, it did not to diminish my idea, percolating even before I saw Fatherland, that Huller's presence in a film is a sure sign of excellent quality. Since this is the tenth anniversary of my awareness of her, it seemed like a good time to fete her a bit.
The thing is, Toni Erdmann did not lead to an immediate breakout for Huller. In fact, the first half of those ten years continued in obscurity for her, at least in terms of international renown. In fact, it was more like seven years. Her movies on IMDB from 2017 to 2022 are a bunch of things I've never heard of, because they're in her native tongue of German and did not reach the rest of us the way Toni Erdmann did.
But starting in 2023? Holy mackeral.
Anatomy of a Fall - A best picture nominee that had the whole world debating about what really happened. Huller was nominated for best actress.
The Zone of Interest - A second best picture nominee in the same year that some people have described as one of the most difficult to watch films they've ever seen.
Project Hail Mary - Proving she could do popcorn movies as well, Huller featured prominently in the big box office phenomenon of the first half of 2026.
Digger - Opinion is, of course, divided on Tom Cruise's latest, but you know that I love it, and I think you'll find that's the way history is ultimately going to view this film.
Rose - I haven't seen this yet and am not actually sure it's been released, but this is one of three movies this year that have Huller as a potential Oscar nominee.
And of course Fatherland.
Not only can Huller pick a winner, but she's even come up with a personal signature. After she sung Harry Styles' "Sign of the Times" in Project Hail Mary -- a song I didn't even know and now love -- that made two prominent Huller karaoke moments. Famously she sung "The Greatest Love of All" in Toni Erdmann, though I have to admit that scene is not a personal favorite.
But let's choose the topic of pop songs in Huller films to transition back to the other thing I want to talk about today.
The other thing that happened this week that pushed me to finally compose this post was that I was listening to an episode of Filmspotting in which they listed their top five needle drops. It came out a few months ago, as I'm still catching up on my podcasts.
What actually constitutes a needle drop was the subject of some debate, but we don't need to get into that right now because it's not relevant to this discussion. What's relevant is that Adam Kempenaar, one of the two hosts, selected as one of his choices the usage of The Cure's "Plainsong" in Marie Antoinette.
It was funny to me that this was not even one of the first few needle drops I thought of in Marie Antoinette. If I'm thinking about music related to Sofia Coppola's third feature, I think first and foremost of her usage of New Order's "Age of Consent" in the trailers, and then of the employment of Bow Wow Wow's "I Want Candy" during that scene with all the cakes and profiteroles.
But sure enough, when Adam mentioned "Plainsong," it came right back to me. It's when Marie and Louis XVI are first introduced as king in queen, and the quiet opening chimes of "Plainsong" resolve into a crashing symbol and just about the most transcendent and majestic wall of sound you've ever heard in your life.
In case you need a reminder:
You know what other movie uses "Plainsong?"
That's right, Toni Erdmann.
And you know when it uses it?
That's right, over the closing credits.
Which is exactly when you are at your moment of greatest contemplation and vulnerability over the experience you've just had.
I'm not saying that "Plainsong" artificially elevated my impression of Toni Erdmann. I mean, I had already laughed harder than I can ever remember laughing at a movie, an experience I was sharing with a packed house, and also cried, at least once.
But was the movie, and director Maren Ade, perniciously focused on making sure I didn't have a chance to doubt myself?
Heck yeah it was. Heck yeah she was.
I feel it's right to be honest with myself about this, in part because I just earlier this month called out another movie for basking in the reflected glow of a song.
I doubt Toni Erdmann and Voicemails for Isabelle have anything else in common than employing a great piece of popular music, but indeed, in this post from November 3rd, I called out Voicemails for leaning too heavily on Robyn's banger "Dancing On My Own." I called it both shrewd and lame.
I do not think Toni Erdmann was lame for using "Plainsong." However, this week's reminder that Coppola had used it nine years earlier in Marie Antoinette, probably giving us something quite original at that time, did indicate to me that the song was undoubtedly doing some work for Toni Erdmann ... even if it was after the rest of the movie was over.
But hey look. The phrase "needle drop" has become a dirty word among some movie fans I know. For me, nothing could be further from the truth. One of the reasons I rewatched The Girl Next Door on Friday is because it has quite simply one of the best curated and best employed collections of beloved popular songs that I've ever heard in a movie.
And since this was only the second time I remembered hearing "Plainsong" used in a movie -- even though I might not have dredged up the Marie Antoinette usage at that time -- it certainly worked on me, guilt free.
Though funnily enough, the internet tells me it was used just the year before in Ant-Man. I really don't remember that.












