Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The big movies bring out the rookies

I lied to you last week. Which is an interesting little nugget for a movie about lying. 

Actually it was really that I was mistaken. I thought I was seeing You Can See Everything on Monday night. In fact it was Tuesday night. Which has finally now passed.

But even if I had been lying, it would have only been a white lie -- in other words, not something that harms anyone and is told more to save feelings or to lubricate interactions. The sort of lie that Elizabeth Holmes says she doesn't ever tell, let alone the massive, defrauding level of lies she was convicted of telling, leading to an 11-year prison sentence.

But if you think this is going to be an examination of Nathan Fielder's and Lance Oppenheim's three-hour documentary, the talk of the movie world, well, I'll disappoint you like a shrewd observer is disappointed trying to plumb the depths of Holmes' soul to see if she even has one. 

I do have some available, spoiler-free You Can See Everything talk in my review, just posted. Of course, that can only ever scratch the surface of a discussion of this film, even if you are including spoilers. 

Instead, I'll talk about the phenomenon I observed last night at the Sun in Yarraville, about how a big movie like this scares up viewers who are obviously pretty rusty at it. 

My wife and I had an early Greek dinner at one of our favorite local restaurants, and were easily in our seats five minutes prior to the 6 p.m. showing. We knew the showing was basically, if not actually, sold out -- even ten days ago, when my wife bought the tickets, it was close to selling out. Yet there were only about 15 to 20 of us in a theater that could hold maybe 200.

Were the rest coming? Had we somehow gotten it wrong that the movie was (almost) sold out? (I saw in the lobby that the showtime was in red, meaning it was only "filling," but not yet crossed out, for sold out.)

No, the other 180-185 people were coming. Just on delay.

See, if you haven't been out to the movies lately, you wouldn't know that the Sun starts its movies on time. If your movie is set to begin at 6 p.m., you better be in your seats by 6:05 or you're going to miss part of the movie. That's because they play zero ads, exactly two trailers, and a short film produced by the theater itself, relating to some sort of local topic of interest. That takes five minutes, and then the movie starts.

So these people who were summoned from the dark corners of their couches and bedrooms and doom scrolling to watch their first movie in a couple years? Well, they assumed they'd have 20 minutes' worth of obnoxious blather before the show started. They figured they could rock up at 6:15 and still have at least five minutes of trailers remaining.

Not so much.

And so it was that people were streaming into the movie for more or less its first 15 minutes, until the theater finally reached saturation. In a 174-minute movie, that works out just fine. I'm sure most of them weren't even lost.

But it did illustrate for me just how many people are unaccustomed to going to the movies nowadays. You might say they were just unaccustomed to this theater, but that argument doesn't really work. At any given time, most of the patrons in a movie theater are coming to their closest cinema. They only have to come from elsewhere if the movie isn't being shown closer to them, but You Can See Everything is even playing at the closest theater to my house, which I rarely attend because they don't accept my critics card. If it's playing there alongside the blockbusters, it's playing everywhere.

If I were being generous, I'd say the 6 p.m. start time was difficult for some of them to make because they had to get off work and get to the cinema.

Maybe having so much discussion and so many vocal reactions stimulated by this movie will bring them back out more often. Twenty twenty-six seems like one of those years that can save the movies, at least in the short run. But it's a tall order to ask each year to contain a You Can See Everything, an Odyssey, an Obsession and a Backrooms. Let's hope 2027 has at least one of those.

No comments: